Natural Cedar Shake vs. BRAVA Synthetic Cedar Shake: A Smart Roofing Choice

Photo credit: BRAVArooftile.com

When evaluating roofing options, homeowners often weigh the timeless aesthetic of natural cedar shakes against the advanced engineering of synthetic alternatives. As BRAVA certified contractors, we at Lab Exteriors believe their synthetic cedar shake stands out in performance, durability, and eco-conscious design—without sacrificing authentic charm. Still on the fence? We’ve researched the 6 main factors to consider when choosing between natural and synthetic cedar shake so you don’t have to. Here’s what you should know:

1. Lifespan & Durability

• Natural Cedar Shake

• Typically lasts 20–30 years with diligent maintenance—but exposure to moisture and insects can shorten lifespan 

• Prone to warping, splitting, and rot over time 

• BRAVA Synthetic Cedar Shake

  • Backed by a 50-year transferable warranty 

  • Engineered for high hail, wind, and freeze/thaw resistance with Class 4 impact rating and excellent UV stability 

  • Won’t warp or split—saving you routine repair headaches

2. Fire & Weather Resistance

• Natural cedar is combustible and often prohibited in fire-prone regions unless chemically treated

• BRAVA offers Class A or C fire ratings, meeting or exceeding building code requirements

• It also resists extreme weather: wind gusts up to 110+ mph, freezing cycles, and hail—without the degradation natural wood faces

3. Maintenance & Color Retention

• Cedar needs frequent staining, sealing, and monitoring for mold or rot 

• BRAVA is maintenance-free, colored throughout with mineral pigments and UV stabilizers—so no repainting or resealing is required

• Long-term vibrancy is backed by lab-tested warranty—unlike cedar’s natural fading

4. Environmental Advantage

• Real cedar shakes necessitate cutting trees—even if sourced sustainably.

• BRAVA is made from compressed recycled plastics and natural minerals, and is fully recyclable at end-of-life 

• This delivers a sustainable solution without sacrificing aesthetics

5. Authentic Aesthetics & Customization

• Cedar’s charm lies in its rustic variation and texture—but can look aging or inconsistent 

• BRAVA replicates hand-split Western Red Cedar, with variable thicknesses and widths, producing realistic shadow lines and multi-tone finishes

• Available in 9–11 colors or custom shades, offering stylistic flexibility .

6. Cost Effectiveness Over Time

• Natural cedar costs $25–$30/ft² plus ongoing maintenance

• BRAVA installs around $14–$18/ft² material cost, often with lower labor due to lighter, uniform panels—translating into long-term savings

• Though upfront cost may be higher than asphalt, the 50‑year durability and low upkeep make BRAVA a sound long-term investment .

Why BRAVA is the Smart Choice

1. Performance-Driven: Superior fire, impact, and weatherproof ratings to handle the variable weather of NOVA.

2. Durability: 50-year warranty, no rot/insect/fade issues.

3. Eco-Responsible: Made from recycled materials, recyclable at end-of-life.

4. Visual Authenticity: Realistic textures and customizable color options.

5. Financially Sensible: Long-term savings through reduced maintenance and enhanced lifespan.

For Virginia homeowners seeking the warmth and texture of cedar with modern reliability, BRAVA synthetic cedar shake offers a compelling balance of beauty, performance, and sustainability. Its advanced features—such as long-lasting color, fire and impact resistance, and eco-friendliness—make it a standout roofing solution. Just remember, installation matters greatly: as certified contractors of BRAVA cedar shake, we’ll ensure your roof performs as beautifully as it looks for decades to come.